Would you rather: TBAY edition

Send this game to your friends and play along.

A Sunset on St. Pete Beach. The sky is orange and yellow, with a dark beach before it in the shadows.

Spring is on the horizon.

Photo by TBAYtoday

Table of Contents

There are countless wonderful things about the Tampa Bay area, but what if you had to choose your very favorites? Today, we’re bringing back the classic slumber party game of “Would you Rather” — get to choosing.

Disclaimer: TBAYtoday is not responsible for any heated debates that may result from this game.

Would you rather...

  • Cheer on the Rays or the Bucs
  • Spend an afternoon at Clearwater Beach or Pass-A-Grille
  • Have a coffee date at Oxford Exchange or Black Crow Coffee Co.
  • Grab fresh produce at the Saturday Morning Market or The Market at Water Street
  • Take your furry friend to The Dog Bar or Pups Pub
  • Spend hours at the St. Petersburg Museum of History or the Tampa Museum of Art
  • Live in St. Petersburg or Tampa (sorry, we had to)

Let us know your responses + if you had as much fun as we did, suggest more rounds for future games.

Results

We asked, and you decided your fate. Most would rather...

  • Cheer on the Bucs. (Lucky for you, we’ve got a season preview guide coming up next month. Stay tuned.)
  • Spend an afternoon at Pass-A-Grille.
  • Take your coffee date to Oxford Exchange.
  • Shop fresh produce at the Saturday Morning Market.
  • This vote was split, so it seems that folks can agree: The Dog Bar 🤝 Pups Pub.
  • Spend hours at The St. Petersburg Museum of History.
  • Drumroll please... the majority of you are St. Pete proud (but only by one vote — it was close).

Note: We love and support all of our local businesses, and we would rather remind everyone this is just a friendly game.

More from TBAYtoday
Fit the Surf n’ Turf Alfredo Sundae and other fair delights into your budget.
Get in on the action this Super Bowl Sunday with six local watch parties featuring big screens, a chili cook-off, and food + drink specials.
These local donation sites will collect items like clothing, home goods, diapers, and other things that people may need.
The grand opening of the alpine event is on Friday, Feb. 6 in Northern Italy. We’re imagining how it would go down in the Tampa Bay area.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
See which Tampa Bay gems made OpenTable’s “2026’s Top 100 Romantic Restaurants.”
Tampa Bay’s beloved coffee joint is making its first move into Pinellas and Sarasota counties.
The city’s long-awaited two-way bike lane is nearly complete.
The new 31-story condo tower is one of the latest changes to the South Tampa skyline.