Support Us Button Widget

7 Tampa Bay pizza slice spots

Sink your teeth into standout slices at these pizza joints across Tampa and St. Petersburg.

A shot of Santoro's Pizza in Tampa. The building is a mix of green, white, and red — the colors of the Italian flag. There are some benches outside, and a parking lot out front, with blue skies up ahead.

On a TBAY pizza tour, Santoro’s is a must.

Sometimes nothing hits like a late-night slice of pizza. Bookmark these sizzlin’ Tampa Bay pizzerias for when you need it:

Due Amici Pizza & Pasta

You can clamber right up to the Ybor City eatery’s glass case for a piping hot slice of stuffed or otherwise topped pizza until the wee hour of 3 a.m.

Santoro’s

Barstool Sports Founder Dave Portnoy rated this North Hyde Park’s ‘za a 7.8. But we really love them for their lunch deal: one plain slice, one specialty slice, and a fountain drink for $7.

Joey Brooklyn’s

Editor Bailey’s late-night slice spot is parked steps away from Jannus Live in downtown St. Pete, for that easy post-concert access. The pieces are massive, and you can choose from plentiful toppings.

Eddie and Sam’s NY Pizza

It’s a downtown Tampa classic for a reason with a plethora of slice options, from classic options to Buffalo chicken. Please note that the giant slices are actually gargantuan.

Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza

Trust us, the strip mall exterior belies the colorful, bustling St. Pete pizza joint within, complete with old school games and red booths. Get a slice of classic cheese pizza for under $5, plus some of their standout garlic knots for the road.

Forbici

What pairs better with happy hour than a slice of the Hyde Park Village’s classic square-shaped margherita or Cup & Char pizza? Not much.

Heights Pizza

Okay, it’s not quite pizza by the slice. But the two-slice Heights deals are pretty close — plus, they come with a drink.

More from TBAYtoday
We’re sharing the backstory of the famed Tampa Halloween celebration, and what happened to it.
Sponsored
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
We’re breaking down a new flooding mitigation project, PSTA line, and 15,000-tile art piece.
Including gifts for significant others, retirees, holiday parties, young people, and gifts that ship fast.
The 3,260-sqft new build features a koi pond, zen garden, rooftop terrace, and swoon-worthy views.
Hunt for Tootsie Rolls, Kit Kats, and tricks across Tampa, St. Pete, Dunedin, and the rest of TBAY.
The city is working to make its inspection process faster and more accessible to more builders and contractors.
Once finished, the $56 million project connect residents across the city with a 12.2-mile loop.
We’re breaking down what you need to know ahead of the 2025-2026 Bolts season.